Link shorteners that are outsourced are in my humble opinion an order of magnitude worse for the internet than they would be if in-house.
The way they accrete URLs over time, and then time passes, and anything can happen (your account gets deactivated, shortener company goes out of business / experiences catastrophic data loss / etc) is just asking for permanently broken links which may be unfixable.
Especially when you consider how these services can, unless they're spammy enough to inject gross interstitial ad pages, make 0 revenue from you if you aren't currently paying for a premium service, it's easy to see how they can go under.
Note: Clearly with the kind of ephemeral crap these 2011 tweets were, I'm assuming the 'attacker' publicized "Hey guys look at these funny tweets" because obviously who cares about 15 year old McDonalds marketing messages. But in general it's sad to see these still being used. To be fair to bitly, they do offer the ability to use your own domain at least, but sadly, with a service targeted mainly at marketing departments, usually they don't have the ability to work with the in-house tech team(s) to even set up DNS.
Yeah, but the alternative is everyone having a short domain, which is unfortunately difficult due to the fundamental mathematical principle that a low amount of characters has a very small number of options available.
Everything with finite space is expensive, the more finite the more expensive.
So, while I am in favour of what you say, and I’m in favour of self-governance as much as possible, I understand the challenges.
>Yeah, but the alternative is everyone having a short domain, which is unfortunately difficult due to the fundamental mathematical principle that a low amount of characters has a very small number of options available.
I get where you're coming from but I'm wondering if that's undersells the value-add of link shorteners as literally just shortening the link.
I remember that I liked using link shorteners because they gave me analytics on who clicked my link and where from. I believe paid QR Code link shorteners operate on a similar principle of offering analytics on where and how QR Codes are discovered.
And while in theory, this should be handled by first-party analytics, the users of link shorteners don't necessarily always have control over that analytics platform (e.g., student researchers driving traffic to a survey on an institutional domain).
The original mass market use of link shorteners was to minimize the number of characters needed to link from a Tweet.
Now that Tweets aren't restricted to 140 bytes anymore, there is less need for every single byte. Maybe the difference between sending 1 SMS per message and 2...
Gee, thanks. Maybe insert some more superfluous facts and observations here, like the atomic number of carbon or maybe the price of tea in China.
"Mass market" is not another way of saying popular. Even if that were the question—whether TinyURL et al were popular before Twitter came along—the answer is a resounding yes.
The claim that "the original mass market use of link shorteners was to minimize the number of characters needed to link from a Tweet" is simply not true.
> but the alternative is everyone having a short domain
Or just not bother.
Practically no one types a URL like that any more aside from a few biggies like BBC.co.uk, Amazon.com, etc, and even those are usually cached in URL history so they only type the first couple of characters. When were you last given a URL by voice, rather than being given a suggestion to “search for [something-or-other]”? The 140 char limit on Twitter¹ is now 280 making a really short URL less important there, those foolish enough to pay for the site can post much longer missives in one go, and I can't think of another popular site with a stringent artificial post length limit. People looking for your stuff by name will search², not type your address in.
I use a deliberately long name for humour value³. Though I host nothing on there that isn't just for me and friends so this is maybe a special case, I doubt that for many sites a short name makes much real difference these days. People who see my stuff do so by clicking a link, not typing anything in.
--------
[1] the social network desperately trying to be known as “X”
[2] or ask AI which amounts to the same thing usually
[3] subdirectories or subdomains (depeding on my mood at the time) of doubleyoudoubledoubleewe.www.dash.deeohhtee.dash-dash.enneeetee.net
If I asked people in public what X is they would be confused what I meant. If I asked what twitter is and then asked what X is they would know the answer to both.
Everyone I know still calls it Twitter, and most blogs I read still do as well.
Calling it Twitter is more universally understandable. Using "X" can cause confusion if someone using a generic "x" as a variable as in "and then A said to X that Y..." For that reason I don't particularly care what the owner of the company wants to call the online equivalent of Kleenux he bought.
Also, my company at the time saw an uptick in account takeovers when HotMail (a popular free email provider) changed their policy to allowing usernames to be recycled. Because email account ownership is basically equivalent to identity proof for most websites, HotMail's policy change effectively cost us a massive customer service workload. (I think the mass liquidity of virtual items out of accounts was more of the direct issue, not so much that users were still active on our site while being inactive on their email account for a year)
The idea of link shorteners are fundamentally stupid. We already have a thing where an arbitrary short word when clicked takes you to another website with arbitrary long URL. It’s called hyperlinks. It’s the first thing invented for the Web ever.
Short anecdote: Famous author (with huge fanbase!) used a Bit.ly link in one of their books (the narrative needed a fake tweet with fake link). Editor didn't notice/care and never registered it. I noticed on release date, caught it and redirected it to a website that referenced the book, a few people tweet about it thinking the author used the link on purpose!
I think the biggest surprise to me is that a URL shortener makes enough money to have a Trust and Safety team. I assumed it was just a side project a person or two ran.
My take is that any shortener without one would voluntarily close doors after being inundated with the most illegal, scammy, and horrid use-cases, and subsequent requests from law enforcement that would far outweigh any ROI.
That won't necessarily protect you. Many of the top 10K domains allow user content I assume, so if you don't have your own 24/7 safety department you are relying on theirs.
If you aren't already, make sure you check your whitelist of domains against the PSL¹ to make sure you know where having some trust in a domain definitely doesn't mean that a subdomain of it can be similarly trusted.
There is a QR code site that lets you create free QR codes. Unbeknownst to the user, all URLs route through their domain to the destination site.
At some point, it stops redirecting and shows a paywall. If you want that QR code you created and put on physical objects to continue working you have to pay a subscription fee.
Bit.ly isn’t that…but you have understand that the business model is mostly people paying you because they feel they have to and not because they want to.
There are many of these. They are, in my opinion, 100% scams and Google/etc shouldn’t be listing these.
The “some point” tends to be after the unknowing victim has ordered physical media/prints with the code, and the “subscription” is $30/month, annual payment required.
You would be surprised. I've worked with many non-technical people who don't seem to understand that a QR code for their poster etc is just a URL, maybe because they don't fully understand what a URL is.
They invariably turn to these freemium or paid services in search results that inject tracking, ads, or limit the number of referrals before payment is required. In fact this happens so often I set up an internal page for them to make their own QR codes with some customization.
Google had a popular link-shortening service for a long time before trust and safety started consuming too much staff time, and they killed it. Considering how often link shorteners are used for scams and illegal stuff, you either need a trust and safety team or you're just waiting for the FBI to knock and do it for you.
The business is actually quite simple: ads on the clicker side and analytics on the business side. And in terms of compliance it's mostly dealing with issues like fraud and malware links. Very much winner take all type of business. Most link shortener side projects go out of business within 6 months, you can find tons of examples on Reddit.
the QR they offer (free today, then you need to pay) is a total scam: but so many professionals cannot spot it until is too late (saw in printed magazines, books ...)
I found it so crazy when people I thought had technical sense do this. I'm always like, you know, QR codes can have the actual URL, right? It's not a magical thing that needs any back end.
Same. It's been marketing and other departments that have claimed to need them for ease of use, but then also that same department wants to shove a lot of long text in the url for SEO...
I've warned several times over the years that these links will rot and our going to be out of our control, but... that's what they want!
These days you can buy a short domain easily and create your own short links.
Right now there are around 540 TLDs that anyone can use (not brands or country restrictions) and most are really cheap and haven't been bought out yet.
> Right now there are around 540 TLDs that anyone can use
Be careful if you care about visits from those using corporate networks, many arbitrarily block uncommon TLDs¹ unless users explicitly ask for the restriction to be dropped².
--------
[1] The reason given being that links on them are often phishing and related crap as they are real useful links
[2] and even then an assessment is made, the drop is not automatic and your site alone is unlikely to be deemed sufficient reason
There's a lot of abandoned url ownership things on the internet. We need something like a bureau that keeps track of what it was for. We do have archive.is or .org to save the content at a url (side note - are these archivers legal or in some country that allows this?).
I do often come across an article occasionally where someone is writing about a narrow topic that I'm interesting in, but I can't find them any more - maybe they had a vauge user name that isn't resolvable.
You have sites trying to block spammers, but you have over-active groups like Reddit that seem to delete accounts aggressively with no information about what you did wrong. I want a meta id that I own, that people can check I'm the real "foo-bar1418", and that can't be deleted or taken over.
It feels like there's still room for a super-crosssite-ID. But there are also spammers, haters etc that sites have to deal with.
archive.org is a 501(c)(3) non-profit run publicly and generally follows the law.
archive.is is run anonymously, has engaged in ddos campaigns in violation of criminal laws just about everywhere, and has used visitors computers in those campaigns making even visiting the site (when you know of their conduct) a way to violate criminal hacking statutes in most countries.
Somewhat related, I've been getting a lot of spam with links to urls of big, reputable, organizations, such as universities.
You'd think that the organization was hacked, but in all these case instead these were old domains that used CNAMEs.
The domain that the CNAME pointed to was once owned and used by the organization, but at some point it was let go, and it ended up being purchased by the spammers.
So, the spammers were able to use links that looked safe, and maybe that also helped with passing spam filters.
Thus, if you manage domains, please keep track of the ones with CNAMEs, recommend the users to tell you when they stop using them, and maybe check every once in a while (better if automatically) that the domain they're pointing to hasn't changed hands.
I'd be curious to know how the spammers find these old cname domains, by the way.
I had this happen to me. I had a CNAME pointing into a domain I let lapse, and some criminal bought up the domain name and used it for malware with my CNAME.
There were probably crawlable HTML links to the CNAME, in my case. It neve had a TLS cert, so it wouldn't have been in Certificate Transparency logs, and the DNS server doesn't allow AXFR to anybody but the actual secondary.
What is the convenience, really? In 2026, we're rarely speaking/reading URL's. Anything on a print ad can be a QR code. Where that doesn't work, you can say, "go to <company> dot com and search for <product>", like how people used to advertise AOL keywords. Or they can put a link to their active promotions above the fold on their home page.
The main convenience seems to be for pranks, plus it's just another vulnerability as described in the article. At best, they're just something else that has to be maintained forever.
There's a lower chance of a link being truncated if it's being forwarded, or copied/pasted or referred into some way.
Also, including named short links in a url is a friendly way to put a link on printed materials, email, etc.
There's lots of relevant uses for link shorteners. Maintaining it forever is for sure a consideration, it's why running one from your own domain lets you own the 301 redirect permanently.
Some of the link shortener projects have some additional features that look useful, but still, running something directly on cloudfront/flare seems hard to overlook.
The tweet that McDonald's Sweden is proud of what they've achieved, redirected to the Wikipedia page for 9/11, is probably the most quintessentially 'Gen Z' joke to the point that dictionaries ought to use it as the example.
I'm guessing some combo of dark humor, and the fact that they don't remember 9/11 so they don't mind joking about it, plus ironically trolling big corporations.
tribute.wmv was made by a millennial in 2002 and trolling big corporations on the internet has been a thing as long big corporations have been on the internet to troll. None of those are even vaguely genz traits.
Basically, bit-rot-ly missed up by deleting old link names when deleting accounts; people now register old links and redirect them to wherever they want.
if the original people had kept their accounts active they would still be the original URL. That's on BK, Trump, etc.
Obviously, them's the breaks though when you voluntarily rent URLs from random companies. Bitly could sell their whole domain to (insert whatever organization you trust the least) and every URL you've ever made either breaks or is redirected to whatever that entity wants.
My company use a shortener to reduce how much data gets encoded into QR codes that we use, thus making them work better in marginal lighting conditions with worse phones. However, it is entirely self-hosted (301/302 redirect is not a difficult service to build) to protect us from this exact kind of problem.
Traditionally they were useful at the height of Twitter's heyday, because it used to limit Tweets to 140 characters. SMS is a similar use case, but I disliked it there even more, because it normalised getting official messages from random shortcodes with shortened links -- just like a phishing campaign.
You certainly can, I'd happily set one up for my company if they'd let me, but the marketing organizations that generally use these things are 99% of the time only distant cousins from people like me in the orgchart family tree. They just go sign up accounts, use a marketing credit card, and do whatever, and they only talk to people in the tech side of the company after some mess or disaster is made (e.g. "Oh no, we used a URL shortener that went out of business/sold to a porn site/etc")
I don't need shorter links per-se but I need a way to track the effectivness of the links I send out to the public for marketing purposes. I could put tracking ids and such but it doesn't look as good.
I also have links to my Google reviews, Google Maps etc and it's better show bitly.com/business-google-reviews and bitly.com/business-google/map than https://maps.app.goo.gl/sGa1KAU2131212cqU7
You want a way, and I can assure you that normal links look better, especially if the tracking part is easier to spot and can be removed by those who want to (who will be a minority, so your statistics won't be affected too much).
The other replies have largely covered most use cases they can also be handy for less tech savvy people to quickly generate links with unique analytics for marketing purposes.
Back in the day every useful link you found on forums used to be shortened with an advertisment proxy service that promised a few pennies per click in exchange for making the user sit through a minute of ads.
Before Twitter, they were used to put URLs on physical things like business cards. They increased in popularity once Twitter imposed a 140 character limit.
People then saw that there were lots of secondary benefits. As another comment mentioned, hiding affiliate forwarders / query strings were a huge use back when everyone was trying to score those kickbacks. And then getting metrics on every clickthrough.
Obviously should probably never use this in the |bash situation, but it's `-L` -- in general a good one to use by default unless you're only using curl to inspect redirect headers or something.
The way they accrete URLs over time, and then time passes, and anything can happen (your account gets deactivated, shortener company goes out of business / experiences catastrophic data loss / etc) is just asking for permanently broken links which may be unfixable.
Especially when you consider how these services can, unless they're spammy enough to inject gross interstitial ad pages, make 0 revenue from you if you aren't currently paying for a premium service, it's easy to see how they can go under.
Note: Clearly with the kind of ephemeral crap these 2011 tweets were, I'm assuming the 'attacker' publicized "Hey guys look at these funny tweets" because obviously who cares about 15 year old McDonalds marketing messages. But in general it's sad to see these still being used. To be fair to bitly, they do offer the ability to use your own domain at least, but sadly, with a service targeted mainly at marketing departments, usually they don't have the ability to work with the in-house tech team(s) to even set up DNS.
Everything with finite space is expensive, the more finite the more expensive.
So, while I am in favour of what you say, and I’m in favour of self-governance as much as possible, I understand the challenges.
I get where you're coming from but I'm wondering if that's undersells the value-add of link shorteners as literally just shortening the link.
I remember that I liked using link shorteners because they gave me analytics on who clicked my link and where from. I believe paid QR Code link shorteners operate on a similar principle of offering analytics on where and how QR Codes are discovered.
And while in theory, this should be handled by first-party analytics, the users of link shorteners don't necessarily always have control over that analytics platform (e.g., student researchers driving traffic to a survey on an institutional domain).
Now that Tweets aren't restricted to 140 bytes anymore, there is less need for every single byte. Maybe the difference between sending 1 SMS per message and 2...
That's an anachronism. URL shorteners predate Twitter by several years. (Even the Wikipedia article for URL shorteners is older than Twitter.)
<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23117242>
… was the original goalpost.
Nobody claimed they didn’t exist at all before Twitter.
Gee, thanks. Maybe insert some more superfluous facts and observations here, like the atomic number of carbon or maybe the price of tea in China.
"Mass market" is not another way of saying popular. Even if that were the question—whether TinyURL et al were popular before Twitter came along—the answer is a resounding yes.
The claim that "the original mass market use of link shorteners was to minimize the number of characters needed to link from a Tweet" is simply not true.
Or just not bother.
Practically no one types a URL like that any more aside from a few biggies like BBC.co.uk, Amazon.com, etc, and even those are usually cached in URL history so they only type the first couple of characters. When were you last given a URL by voice, rather than being given a suggestion to “search for [something-or-other]”? The 140 char limit on Twitter¹ is now 280 making a really short URL less important there, those foolish enough to pay for the site can post much longer missives in one go, and I can't think of another popular site with a stringent artificial post length limit. People looking for your stuff by name will search², not type your address in.
I use a deliberately long name for humour value³. Though I host nothing on there that isn't just for me and friends so this is maybe a special case, I doubt that for many sites a short name makes much real difference these days. People who see my stuff do so by clicking a link, not typing anything in.
--------
[1] the social network desperately trying to be known as “X”
[2] or ask AI which amounts to the same thing usually
[3] subdirectories or subdomains (depeding on my mood at the time) of doubleyoudoubledoubleewe.www.dash.deeohhtee.dash-dash.enneeetee.net
I’m not going to change my vocabulary just because some company wants me to. Or individual person, or social movement for that matter.
BBC news and podcasts still often refer to it as Twitter or "X, formally Twitter".
We will call things as we like and corpo marketers can't do anything about it
Calling it Twitter is more universally understandable. Using "X" can cause confusion if someone using a generic "x" as a variable as in "and then A said to X that Y..." For that reason I don't particularly care what the owner of the company wants to call the online equivalent of Kleenux he bought.
Also, my company at the time saw an uptick in account takeovers when HotMail (a popular free email provider) changed their policy to allowing usernames to be recycled. Because email account ownership is basically equivalent to identity proof for most websites, HotMail's policy change effectively cost us a massive customer service workload. (I think the mass liquidity of virtual items out of accounts was more of the direct issue, not so much that users were still active on our site while being inactive on their email account for a year)
If you aren't already, make sure you check your whitelist of domains against the PSL¹ to make sure you know where having some trust in a domain definitely doesn't mean that a subdomain of it can be similarly trusted.
--------
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Suffix_List
At some point, it stops redirecting and shows a paywall. If you want that QR code you created and put on physical objects to continue working you have to pay a subscription fee.
Bit.ly isn’t that…but you have understand that the business model is mostly people paying you because they feel they have to and not because they want to.
The “some point” tends to be after the unknowing victim has ordered physical media/prints with the code, and the “subscription” is $30/month, annual payment required.
They invariably turn to these freemium or paid services in search results that inject tracking, ads, or limit the number of referrals before payment is required. In fact this happens so often I set up an internal page for them to make their own QR codes with some customization.
Unlike link shorteners, the URL length barely matters, and the codes often get permanently printed onto posters, tables, art, etc.
the QR they offer (free today, then you need to pay) is a total scam: but so many professionals cannot spot it until is too late (saw in printed magazines, books ...)
Have a look at trustpilot reviews
I've warned several times over the years that these links will rot and our going to be out of our control, but... that's what they want!
Right now there are around 540 TLDs that anyone can use (not brands or country restrictions) and most are really cheap and haven't been bought out yet.
Be careful if you care about visits from those using corporate networks, many arbitrarily block uncommon TLDs¹ unless users explicitly ask for the restriction to be dropped².
--------
[1] The reason given being that links on them are often phishing and related crap as they are real useful links
[2] and even then an assessment is made, the drop is not automatic and your site alone is unlikely to be deemed sufficient reason
I do often come across an article occasionally where someone is writing about a narrow topic that I'm interesting in, but I can't find them any more - maybe they had a vauge user name that isn't resolvable.
You have sites trying to block spammers, but you have over-active groups like Reddit that seem to delete accounts aggressively with no information about what you did wrong. I want a meta id that I own, that people can check I'm the real "foo-bar1418", and that can't be deleted or taken over.
It feels like there's still room for a super-crosssite-ID. But there are also spammers, haters etc that sites have to deal with.
archive.is is run anonymously, has engaged in ddos campaigns in violation of criminal laws just about everywhere, and has used visitors computers in those campaigns making even visiting the site (when you know of their conduct) a way to violate criminal hacking statutes in most countries.
You'd think that the organization was hacked, but in all these case instead these were old domains that used CNAMEs.
The domain that the CNAME pointed to was once owned and used by the organization, but at some point it was let go, and it ended up being purchased by the spammers.
So, the spammers were able to use links that looked safe, and maybe that also helped with passing spam filters.
Thus, if you manage domains, please keep track of the ones with CNAMEs, recommend the users to tell you when they stop using them, and maybe check every once in a while (better if automatically) that the domain they're pointing to hasn't changed hands.
I'd be curious to know how the spammers find these old cname domains, by the way.
There were probably crawlable HTML links to the CNAME, in my case. It neve had a TLS cert, so it wouldn't have been in Certificate Transparency logs, and the DNS server doesn't allow AXFR to anybody but the actual secondary.
I guess that they either looked directly for them intentionally, or there's some list of them you can buy in spamners networks.
The main convenience seems to be for pranks, plus it's just another vulnerability as described in the article. At best, they're just something else that has to be maintained forever.
Also, including named short links in a url is a friendly way to put a link on printed materials, email, etc.
There's lots of relevant uses for link shorteners. Maintaining it forever is for sure a consideration, it's why running one from your own domain lets you own the 301 redirect permanently.
2. Podcasts are a thing that exists
Wouldn't it make more sense to restore the original destination URL?
Obviously, them's the breaks though when you voluntarily rent URLs from random companies. Bitly could sell their whole domain to (insert whatever organization you trust the least) and every URL you've ever made either breaks or is redirected to whatever that entity wants.
https://x.com/realdonaldtrump/status/228935671061020673?a=87...
https://x.com/realdonaldtrump/status/350628162595590148?a=Jk...
Traditionally they were useful at the height of Twitter's heyday, because it used to limit Tweets to 140 characters. SMS is a similar use case, but I disliked it there even more, because it normalised getting official messages from random shortcodes with shortened links -- just like a phishing campaign.
Or for historical context, this is all Twitter's fault since its character limit included links too.
And many of them provide analytics to see who’s clicking your link.
I also have links to my Google reviews, Google Maps etc and it's better show bitly.com/business-google-reviews and bitly.com/business-google/map than https://maps.app.goo.gl/sGa1KAU2131212cqU7
I host my own now, for free and for fun.
It's lovely when books use them, and by the time you read them they don't work anymore.
People then saw that there were lots of secondary benefits. As another comment mentioned, hiding affiliate forwarders / query strings were a huge use back when everyone was trying to score those kickbacks. And then getting metrics on every clickthrough.
Imagine if someone is using curl | bash on a shortened URL because "it's too long" and you can't see where the link is going.