This is actually useful for corporate design work. Like you said, Claude et al are mediocre at copying internal design systems well without help. This probably solves a problem for the sites you’re spoofing, so they can vibe code on their own site.
tbh its pretty disheartening to see a project like this make it onto the frontpage when I can't get anything to trend without asking HN nicely by email to put mine into the 2nd chance pool. I have to assume people are boting. im not a fan.
Ah, I have been surprised myself that it generated any interest, but apparently it did. Not sure why you think bots pumped it up.
My goal was to build a pixel-perfect UI coding tool for me, and this one ended up being an experiment I wanted to share. Why does it have to be negative?
Of course people are botting and comments/threads here are manipulated by admins as well. It's not that uncommon to see some bullshit on HN front page with zero comments and 100 upvotes, while threads critical of certain companies get mysteriously deranked and hidden despite huge interest and comments.
I feel like this one is trending for the opposite reason of most projects on this site. I haven't seen much support but it's still an interesting idea. Anybody who knows what it takes to build great software knows that those goobers touting 10k/month in a weekend are lying anyways. Sure those posts get clicks but they don't get much else.
this one is trending because of bots. I wont accept that this is a popular or interesting idea. this is on the level of discovering that you can walk into McDonalds 1 time every day and take as many ketchup packets as you want *and heres the cool part they never find out* no thanks.
To quote the guidelines[1]:
> Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, brigading, foreign agents, and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll look at the data.
Personally, I thought this was a decently entertaining idea and was a nice break from AI hype and other slightly depressing news.
Also, HN is generally very random - some things succeed and others don't. While I understand the sentiment, imo your message came off a bit abrasive haha.
You are wrong, but also the other guy is wrong if someone wanted to fake it they could do it themselves probably with photoshop or inspect element long ago so bad actors were already doing this. Sure maybe not an excuse for enabling it at the click of a few buttons.
Ah, my thought was also that "people are already doing this anyway..." but I agree this makes it more accessible for people who might not have spent that much time on it.
Perfect for Linkedin influencers :)
Why make it more accessible for people to be scammy and lie? Even though it is easy enough for a competent actor, I think you should consider taking this service down. Nothing good can come of it.
Personally, I thought this was a decently entertaining idea and was a nice break from AI hype and other slightly depressing news.
Also, HN is generally very random - some things succeed and others don't. While I understand the sentiment, imo your message came off a bit abrasive haha.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
The site is a hilarious idea but I have a very hard time believing someone will be paying for a Pro account