A lot of this sounded (from a quick read) interesting and insightful.
I wasn't sure about these two paragraphs:
> If AI had started a new wave, there would have been an extended period of uncertainty and experimentation. There would have been a population of early adopters experimenting with their own models. When thousands or millions of tinkerers use the tech to solve problems in entirely new ways, its uses proliferate. But because they are using models owned by the big AI companies, their ability to fully experiment is limited to what’s allowed by the incumbents, who have no desire to permit an extended challenge to the status quo.
> This doesn’t mean AI can’t start the next technological revolution. It might, if experimentation becomes cheap, distributed and permissionless—like Wozniak cobbling together computers in his garage, Ford building his first internal combustion engine in his kitchen, or Trevithick building his high-pressure steam engine as soon as James Watt’s patents expired. When any would-be innovator can build and train an LLM on their laptop and put it to use in any way their imagination dictates, it might be the seed of the next big set of changes—something revolutionary rather than evolutionary. But until and unless that happens, there can be no irruption.
> ... In the 1970s, it took time for people to wrap their heads around the desirability of powerful and ubiquitous computing. But in 2025, machines that think better than previous machines are easy for people to understand.
Even if tinkerers aren't currently training frontier LLMs from scratch, there's still a lot of experimentation happening, and I don't think everyone even realizes yet how transformative this technology will be. On the contrary, there are a lot of skeptics.
That said, it's a good question, who captures the value.
The computer version of this would read something like:
> When any would-be innovator can grow and etch a silicon CPU in their kitchen and put it to use in any way their imagination dictates, it might be the seed of the next big set of changes—something revolutionary rather than evolutionary. But until and unless that happens, there can be no irruption.
Put that way, it seems clear this whole reaction is a category error.
On the question of tinkerers, I'm reminded of the man who just copy-pasted the middle layers of an LLM on top of each other: https://dnhkng.github.io/posts/rys/.
>Even if tinkerers aren't currently training frontier LLMs from scratch, there's still a lot of experimentation happening, and I don't think everyone even realizes yet how transformative this technology will be.
The big issue of vendor lock-in remains for the frontier models. We saw a small piece of this in the games industry when people started reverse compiling games at unprecedented speeds, and companies' answer was to push Anthropic to refusing to process such prompts. A very easy workaround for now, but they played their hand and revealed their allegiance.
Any innovation that threatens to disrupt with current structures will be stifled by the old guard.
> I don't think everyone even realizes yet how transformative this technology will be. On the contrary, there are a lot of skeptics.
Same occurred back at the start of the cloud era where sysadmins were certain no sane business owner would up load their business to the cloud
And well...all those businesses were run by nut jobs
Whole lot of IT people are hung up on linguistics and refuse to acknowledge there's a physical component of the machine and ultimately we're managing machine states for the users need not contextualizing machine needs with layers of dev abstraction
If devs were carpenters they'd have diamond crusted hammers and debate the visual splendor all day never finishing the house
Little nugget at the start that turned out to be very accurate at least with regards to data centers:
> In contrast, society did not need a bubble to pop to start excoriating AI. Given that the backlash to tech has been going on for a decade, this seems normal to us. But the AI backlash differs from the general high regard, earlier in the cycle, enjoyed by the likes of Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos, and others who built big tech businesses. The world hates change, and only gave tech a pass in the ‘80s and ‘90s because it all still seemed reversible: it could be made to go away if it turned out badly. This gave the early computer innovators some leeway to experiment. Now that everyone knows computers are here to stay, AI is not allowed the same wait-and-see attitude. It is seen as part of the ICT revolution.
One of the things that keeps surprising me about the AI build out is that there’s assumptions about usage which run directly counter to the public’s general hatred of this technology. It’s possible it’ll get more hidden and people will use it but unlike PCs or the internet it’s not that there’s an early adopter and a late adopter who just isn’t exposed yet. Instead there’s the early adopter who loves the technology and everyone else who actively dislikes the technology.
The "cool" thing about AI is that is that if it works out as well as possible it eventually makes everyone poor by entirely breaking our economic system but in a moatless way.
1) Massive job loss
2) Reduction of need in companies of any employee size including 1 (when you don't need employees, you don't need a company, companies are just a collection of experts).
People like to talk about "1 person billion dollar companies" but if that person is just driving LLMs what value do they really bring? Even if you assume they have some unique quality of taste or very esoteric knowledge, anything they do can be easily replicated by other people copying them using LLMs causing an immediate race to the bottom.
3) Nobody to sell even the intelligence to. Capitalism implodes.
Tomorrows Anthropic IPO will create something like 4,000 millionaires just from the employee base.
Some people just believe whatever they want to believe, and people whose value to society comes from their ability to write want to believe that AI is without value.
In a decade this will all be quietly forgotten, like the people who claimed the dotcom thing was 'just a fad' after the bubble burst.
I wasn't sure about these two paragraphs:
> If AI had started a new wave, there would have been an extended period of uncertainty and experimentation. There would have been a population of early adopters experimenting with their own models. When thousands or millions of tinkerers use the tech to solve problems in entirely new ways, its uses proliferate. But because they are using models owned by the big AI companies, their ability to fully experiment is limited to what’s allowed by the incumbents, who have no desire to permit an extended challenge to the status quo.
> This doesn’t mean AI can’t start the next technological revolution. It might, if experimentation becomes cheap, distributed and permissionless—like Wozniak cobbling together computers in his garage, Ford building his first internal combustion engine in his kitchen, or Trevithick building his high-pressure steam engine as soon as James Watt’s patents expired. When any would-be innovator can build and train an LLM on their laptop and put it to use in any way their imagination dictates, it might be the seed of the next big set of changes—something revolutionary rather than evolutionary. But until and unless that happens, there can be no irruption.
> ... In the 1970s, it took time for people to wrap their heads around the desirability of powerful and ubiquitous computing. But in 2025, machines that think better than previous machines are easy for people to understand.
Even if tinkerers aren't currently training frontier LLMs from scratch, there's still a lot of experimentation happening, and I don't think everyone even realizes yet how transformative this technology will be. On the contrary, there are a lot of skeptics.
That said, it's a good question, who captures the value.
> When any would-be innovator can grow and etch a silicon CPU in their kitchen and put it to use in any way their imagination dictates, it might be the seed of the next big set of changes—something revolutionary rather than evolutionary. But until and unless that happens, there can be no irruption.
Put that way, it seems clear this whole reaction is a category error.
Turns out you can just do that!
The big issue of vendor lock-in remains for the frontier models. We saw a small piece of this in the games industry when people started reverse compiling games at unprecedented speeds, and companies' answer was to push Anthropic to refusing to process such prompts. A very easy workaround for now, but they played their hand and revealed their allegiance.
Any innovation that threatens to disrupt with current structures will be stifled by the old guard.
Same occurred back at the start of the cloud era where sysadmins were certain no sane business owner would up load their business to the cloud
And well...all those businesses were run by nut jobs
Whole lot of IT people are hung up on linguistics and refuse to acknowledge there's a physical component of the machine and ultimately we're managing machine states for the users need not contextualizing machine needs with layers of dev abstraction
If devs were carpenters they'd have diamond crusted hammers and debate the visual splendor all day never finishing the house
> In contrast, society did not need a bubble to pop to start excoriating AI. Given that the backlash to tech has been going on for a decade, this seems normal to us. But the AI backlash differs from the general high regard, earlier in the cycle, enjoyed by the likes of Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, Jeff Bezos, and others who built big tech businesses. The world hates change, and only gave tech a pass in the ‘80s and ‘90s because it all still seemed reversible: it could be made to go away if it turned out badly. This gave the early computer innovators some leeway to experiment. Now that everyone knows computers are here to stay, AI is not allowed the same wait-and-see attitude. It is seen as part of the ICT revolution.
One of the things that keeps surprising me about the AI build out is that there’s assumptions about usage which run directly counter to the public’s general hatred of this technology. It’s possible it’ll get more hidden and people will use it but unlike PCs or the internet it’s not that there’s an early adopter and a late adopter who just isn’t exposed yet. Instead there’s the early adopter who loves the technology and everyone else who actively dislikes the technology.
As an early adopter I would not say I love the technology. I just keep it around because I know I have to.
https://get.mem.ai/blog/mem-is-shutting-down
1) Massive job loss
2) Reduction of need in companies of any employee size including 1 (when you don't need employees, you don't need a company, companies are just a collection of experts).
People like to talk about "1 person billion dollar companies" but if that person is just driving LLMs what value do they really bring? Even if you assume they have some unique quality of taste or very esoteric knowledge, anything they do can be easily replicated by other people copying them using LLMs causing an immediate race to the bottom.
3) Nobody to sell even the intelligence to. Capitalism implodes.
this is sure a remarkably pure example.
This is right up there with "humans will never achieve flight" and "humans will die of asphyxiation at 100 mph" or whatever.
Some people just believe whatever they want to believe, and people whose value to society comes from their ability to write want to believe that AI is without value.
In a decade this will all be quietly forgotten, like the people who claimed the dotcom thing was 'just a fad' after the bubble burst.